Weather
Critics claim council waste strategy in tatters (From Darlington and Stockton Times)
Send us your pictures, video, news and views by texting DST to 80360 or email us
Critics claim council waste strategy in tatters
2:52pm Thursday 25th September 2008
CRITICS claim a council's waste strategy is in tatters after possible plans for an incinerator near Dalton, Thirsk, were criticised by a planning inspector.
North Yorkshire County Council selected Dalton Airfield Industrial Estate as one of seven possible sites for an incinerator, prompting residents to set up the Dalton Incinerator Steering Committee (Disc) last year to fight the idea.
Disc claims an incinerator on the estate would lead to serious problems. Members fears pollutants from the burning process, saying the incinerator could be just 800m from homes and would threaten health.
Planning inspector Jonathan King recently held a public examination of the council's minerals and waste development framework core strategy, of which the incinerator is a part.
The hearing, at which the council and Disc were present, was halted on its second day to allow the council to review its position.
David Andrews, chairman of Disc, said: "The county council is trying to make the best of it.
"The inspector told the council there were too many issues going on and he advised the council to go away and look at its position.
"He decided he was unlikely to be happy with the evidence presented by the council and has asked it to consider its position.
"The background to this is that the council was warned at the preparatory meeting that the inspector had serious concerns which needed addressing.
"The examiner explained that far more serious issues lay ahead, which the meeting had not yet discussed at all.
"We presented a logical and convincing case that the council had ignored consistent public consultation results showing deep concerns against incineration."
Coun Bill Barton, the county councillor for Dalton, has already spoken out against the scheme and pledged his support to the Disc group.
The county council claims it asked for the public examination to be suspended to allow it to revise its scheme.
Richard Flinton, director of business and economic services, said: "By seeking a suspension in the public examination, we have gained the opportunity to address the issues raised by the inspector in the light of new guidance, the experience of other local authorities, and recent case law."
An exploratory meeting between Mr King and the council has now been scheduled to be held on November 11 to agree a way forward.
The council claims the public examination into the core strategy will probably resume in the new year.
The county council has not yet selected a site and when it does, the scheme will still need planning approval.
The other possible sites listed are at Allerton Park Quarry, Boroughbridge; Tancred Quarry, Catterick; Barnsdale Bar Quarry, Selby; Gateforth Park Farm, Selby; Burn Airfield, Selby; and Gascoinge Wood mine site, Sherburn in Elmet.
Contact Disc at 3A Kirkgate, Thirsk, YO7 1PX.
More News stories
- Soldier named in crash on A1 killed
- Nature reserve to double in size
- Keeping track of waste on the move
- Go-getting student heads for Sri Lanka and TV fame
- Intrepid girls in leap of faith
- Bid to reduce grim toll as biker deaths reach 15
- Shop damaged after frier fire
- Soldiers 560-mile march to raise awareness of TA
- Rescue team joins mountaineer's bid
- Charity team scales Yorkshire's three highest peaks
Your Say YourNorth-East
DideT, BOLTBY says...
2:48pm Mon 29 Sep 08
The fumes for the proposed incinerator could reach as far as sixteen miles from Dalton. For an area earning a significant proportion of its income from tourism an incinerator proposal seems barmy. As an owner of an accomodation establishment I am very concerned about the effect these proposals will have on my business.
Your sayYour North-East
Add your comment
Register for a FREE Darlington and Stockton Times account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.
Please register now or sign in below to continue.
Local advertisers
Local Information
Enter your postcode, town or place name
The_old_cynic, Sessay says...
5:02pm Fri 26 Sep 08
When meetings relating to this have been held, they have been “conveniently”, around Christmas and bank holidays with little notification giving people little if any time to arrange attendance.
No one disputes that we have a growing problem with waste but the primary actions should be to generate less and recycle more both of which are given passing attention in the NYCC policy.
Incineration should come towards the end for anything not recycled or composted.
Early documents, suggested that the majority of the waste is apparently to come from York, Selby and Scarborough so in an era when we are trying to avoid carbon miles, the correct location would be somewhere between those three. If we accept that we must transport it then why not take it the few extra miles it needs to Haverton Hill where an incinerator is built and awaiting business. Its outfall goes across the estuary and out sea so its impacts should be less and the very large amount of capital needed to build these plants is already invested.
The site at Dalton is an industrial estate which contains food processing factories and is surrounded by farms a reasonable number of which are organic, a status they would lose if this was built. Most of these businesses would probably fail if this site was to be chosen.
Its been known in the USA for years that this technology generates nasty pollutants which have to be monitored correctly but the UK government does not seem to have a strategy for monitoring and policing incinerators to ensure they are not pushing out carcinogenic particulates.