Father of single punch killing victim welcomes Attorney General consideration on similar case

PUNCH VICTIM: Andrew Gibson, who was killed by a single punch in a Darlington nightclub

PUNCH VICTIM: Andrew Gibson, who was killed by a single punch in a Darlington nightclub

First published in News
Last updated
Darlington and Stockton Times: Photograph of the Author by , Regional Chief Reporter

THE father of a soldier killed by a single punch outside a North-East nightclub has welcomed the Attorney General’s decision to consider referring a similar case to the Court of Appeal.

Andrew Young, 40, died after being struck by Lewis Gill, 20, in Bournemouth, Dorset, on November 6 last year, in a vicious assault caught on CCTV.

Gill later pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced at Salisbury Crown Court to four-and-a-half years in prison - a sentence reportedly branded an absolute joke by Mr Young’s family.

The Attorney General’s Office has confirmed it is considering whether to refer the sentence to the Court of Appeal for being unduly lenient after receiving complaints. Only one complaint is required to trigger the process.

In December 2009, 19-year-old Andrew Gibson, a soldier based at Catterick Garrison, died six days after being punched in Escapades nightclub in Darlington.

Seventeen-year-old John Flannigan was sentenced to just two-and-a-half years in prison for the manslaughter, prompting The Northern Echo to launch its Price of a Punch campaign, demanding tougher penalties for one-punch killers.

Following the conviction, Andrew’s parents, Freddy and Linda Gibson, of Cumbernauld, Glasgow, expressed their shock at the length of the sentence and urged the Attorney General to send the case to the Court of Appeal, which has powers to increase jail terms.

Despite the Attorney General refusing to refer their case, the couple welcomed his consideration on the latest single-punch conviction.

Mr Gibson said: “People have to pay the price for their actions but at the moment that price is too lenient.

“They are getting away with what in my eyes is murder.”

Darlington MP Jenny Chapman, who has supported the Echo campaign since its launch, added that sentencing in single-punch killing cases appeared to be unduly lenient.

“I’m pleased the Attorney General is looking at this. To say you didn’t mean it or you were drunk is no defence.”

The Attorney General has until March 21 to decide whether to refer the Gill sentence to the Court of Appeal.

CCTV images of the assault show Asperger's sufferer Mr Young challenging a cyclist who was riding his bike on the pavement.

After one minute of discussion between the pair, Gill - an acquaintance of the cyclist - arrives at the scene.

The cyclist rides off and Gill appears to turn to follow him - but suddenly lunges towards Mr Young and launches a single vicious punch at his head.

Mr Young immediately falls on to the ground, where he lies motionless.

Gill, of Sutton in south London, glances back at him before callously walking away.

Dorset Police released the CCTV images, which were shown to the sentencing judge.

The incident happened on November 6 last year outside the Tesco Metro store in Charminster Road, Bournemouth.

Mr Young suffered a serious head injury and later died in Southampton Hospital.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:53pm Wed 26 Feb 14

peanutjones says...

"one punch" manslaughter sentences are far too lenient, almost trivial. Although there is no specific intent to kill, the risk of death is quite high if the victim is on the street where they are likely to hit heir head on concrete and suffer brain injury. The victim is still dead, and the guilty are back out within a short period of time.
"one punch" manslaughter sentences are far too lenient, almost trivial. Although there is no specific intent to kill, the risk of death is quite high if the victim is on the street where they are likely to hit heir head on concrete and suffer brain injury. The victim is still dead, and the guilty are back out within a short period of time. peanutjones
  • Score: 11

8:46am Thu 27 Feb 14

st-george1 says...

Like millions of others I too have little or NO confidence in what they do or say … and suggests there really is a post code lottery in England when it comes to sentencing some people who murder someone
GOD HELP US ALL, it’s frightening to think our lives might one day be in the hands of these pretentious Judiciary and desperate CPS people !
Like millions of others I too have little or NO confidence in what they do or say … and suggests there really is a post code lottery in England when it comes to sentencing some people who murder someone GOD HELP US ALL, it’s frightening to think our lives might one day be in the hands of these pretentious Judiciary and desperate CPS people ! st-george1
  • Score: 5

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree